All about the Eye Liners

Hello lovelies! ^^

It's been awhile since I last blog.

Am very inspired by the many bloggers who did the concept of product empties so below are my product empties specifically for eyeliners....

I love eyeliners as it helps me to accentuate or beautify the shape of my eyes. I love to draw dramatic eyes once in a while, but as of lately, I love to only draw the tails for a more natural look, not the whole of the upper lash line. I love tight lining too so it is important for me to get pencil liners.

I cannot exactly remember when I bought them all. Probably starting from early 2013 until now.

#7, #8, & #9 are not empty yet but I figure it's good to blog them together here for easy comparison :)



  • PRODUCTS
#1: MAYBELLINE New York Hyper Diamonds Liquid Liner (black)
#2: KATE eyeliner (BR-1)
#3: Nachu Deka eyeliner (brown)
#4: ETUDE HOUSE Drawing Show Brush Liner (BK801)
#5: Miss Hana (the complete review is here)
#6: IN2IT Pencil Tip Waterproof Gel Liner (WG02 dark brown) *free sharpener*
#7: Holika Holika Jewel-Light Waterproof Eyeliner (08)
#8: A'PIEU Nature Color Gel Eyeliner (01, brown)
#9: ESSENCE Eyeliner Pen Waterproof (01, black)


  • TEST TIME
From A>B>C>D.
A: color intensity and thickness of line.
B: running them under water.
C: run them again under water.
D: I also rubbed under the running tap and this is the result.
*all almost washed off, especially #4*


A>B>C>D.
A: Color intensity and thickness of line.
B: run them under water.
C: see the slight smear of the black liner.
D: after rubbing them with the running tap, this is the result.
*#6 lightened a lot but #7 still looks untouched*


A>B>C>D.
As seen, this gel liner is the strongest in being waterproof and smearproof. Amazing! !


  • Pros and cons of each eyeliners :


1: Good for party and easy to adjust thickness of lines.
    Bad part is it takes some time to dry up and also it is not waterproof.
2: Good to use when new and very natural looking.
    Bad point is the color intensity is less concentrated when apply on the skin after three to     four months of inconsistent usage. Not waterproof too.
3: Felt tip is hard felt tip kind. Just don't really like to use it though I love how the color             makes everything looks natural. Non-waterproof.
4: Of soft felt tip liner. Have a metal ball inside to reduce the rate of drying for the liner           liquid inside. Quite nice to use but the color intensity reduces making it harder to apply       on the eyes. Non-waterproof.
5: Medium hard felt tip of smaller size. It isn't waterproof at all and I can easily remove the     eye liner with my fingers.
6: Good thing is I bought it cheap, for only RM9 at Parkson and there's a free sharpener.       Love how smooth when I glide the pencil on my eyelid. Unfortunately, it breaks when I       use about 3/4 of it and sharpen all the way but it still breaks so I give up. :(
7: Very water-resistant. But not smooth when apply on skin (hands/eye lid) so it looks nit       that nice or natural as expected it to be.
8: Very good in being waterproof and smudgeproof. However it is very dry such that I do       not know how to use. All these while I have been using brush-like or felt kind of                   eyeliners which will glide on smoothly. This is just dry. Even if I add water on my brush       it is still not that smooth.... please help me!!! :o
9: I bought it because I need one and it said that it is waterproof. The test is just                     disappointing. Love how the thickness of lines can be easily adjusted :)

Overall, I would recommend A PIEU if it is smooth during the application but it is not for me.
For non-waterproof, I highly recommend IN2IT  Waterproof Gel liner (pencil tip) & also ETUDE HOUSE Drawing Show Brush Liner / ESSENCE Eyeliner Pen Waterproof (not waterproof).

Please recommend me eyeliners you like that are waterproof and also non-waterproof.
:)

No comments